Is Your Saxophone Setup All It Can Be?
We spend hours practicing our instrument (well, at least some of us). We bust our chops trying to sound better all the time. Playing long tones, scales, etudes, harmonics, learning tunes, soloing over changes, taking lessons – you know what I’m talking about.
Hard work works every time, but sometimes it’s worth asking – “am I working harder or smarter?” Smarter is always the way to go.
What if I were to tell you that you were likely to make a massive improvement in your playing just by taking a littile time to try out some different equipment such as reeds, ligature, and mouthpieces? Heck, you may even want to try playing on some different horns altogether to see how that works.
Comfort Zones are Dangerous
It’s so easy to blindly play the same setup year after year. We might never consider that there might be a richer sounding reed out there for us. Or perhaps we can make our reeds more responsive with a different ligature. Maybe we can get that brighter sound we were looking for just by spending an hour or so at a music store trying out mouthpieces and making a change.
Figure Out if Your Setup is the Best One for You
I recently decided to do a quick survey of some of the major brands of reeds out there to see for myself if the Vandoren Java reeds that I’d been playing for the past 15-plus years were really the best I could do. So I headed over to the local music store and picked up reeds from six different brands, trying out three reeds per brand.
By the time I was done, it was crystal-clear that the Vandoren ZZ reeds worked better for me than even my beloved Java’s.
Here’s what I did to come to the conclusion that there was a better reed out there for me:
- Purchased 3 samples of 6 different brands of reed. (Vandoren Java, Vandoren Java Red, Vandoren ZZ, Vandoren V16, LaVoz,, and Rico Royal).
- Spent one day playing on each reed for five minutes or so, making notes on each reed such as the sound quality, consistency of sound quality between the three reeds, tonal characteristics, responsiveness, etc.
- Spend the next day recording myself on each reed
- After recording on each reed, I knew which brand was the best for me and which brands sounded like a poop sandwich, but I listened back to the recording to hear the difference for myself.
The funny thing is, the tone quality between each brand of reed was way less obvious than it felt while playing the reeds. But that’s not the point. A reed, mouthpiece, ligature, or saxophone has to sound and feel great in order for me to play great. A good setup can not only improve our tone, but it can also make playing a whole lot more fun. And when everything sounds and feels better to us, we’ve got the holy spirit of music flowing through our blood. And when “the spirit” sets in, what comes out of the horn is more accurate, more inspired, and just plain better.
Compare the few hours I spent auditioning reeds to the weeks, months, and years it would have taken me to get that same improvement toiling in the practice room with my same old setup.
Larry Weintraub
December 12, 2013 @ 8:24 pm
Doron:
I did the same thing years ago using different ligatures on my metal FL Link 8*. Then in recent years I was involved in a couple of recording projects, some live recorded with Mini Disk recorders and some studio.
For me what seems to work best on my mpc is a Silver Selmer Ligature for metal mpcs coupled with a plain Orange Box Rico 2.5 reed. I have also found that a reed that is slightly harder seems to record better than a soft reed. They seem to play in tune better.
I’m not talking about going up a strength to record. I just pick a 2.5 reed that’s a bit harder with more core to the sound. How do you feel about that Doron, what is your opinion.
Lately I have also been liking Roberto’s RW 2.5 Hard reeds. The only problem is they are darn expensive, $41 @ box. Also sometimes he gets out of stock for months.
Have a nice holiday. I know you already had Chanukah like me. Have a nice day anyway.
Doron Orenstein
December 16, 2013 @ 2:16 pm
Hey Larry! Not sure exactly what you’re asking – are you asking my opinion on which brand of reed is a bit harder than the Orange Box Rico?
Hope you had a nice Chanukah as well. :-)
Larry Weintraub
December 16, 2013 @ 5:22 pm
Doron:
Thanks for the Happy Chanukah, hope yours was well too. Actually no what I wanted to know was your opinion about recording regardless of the brand of reed. From experience I feel that a slightly harder reed records better than a softer reed. The intonation seems better with a slightly harder reed.
So what is your take on this?
Larry W
Doron Orenstein
December 21, 2013 @ 10:40 pm
Oh, well, in general, I think that if you are going to be playing with less volume, and your sound is going to be more exposed, I think that you’ll need the subtlety that a softer (or at least, not-terribly-hard) reed gives you. Of course, not too soft, but enough so that half of the sound isn’t air.
Likewise, if you’re going to be playing with a high level of volume and intensity, you’ll want something harder that won’t shut down on you when you put a lot of air through the horn.
So I my answer is “it depends.” But I also think that this applies to live performance as well as recordings, I’m not sure if I see a distinction just in recording.
Larry Weintraub
December 22, 2013 @ 7:59 am
Doron:
Thanks for your opinion.
Larry W
Andy
April 2, 2015 @ 1:00 am
Fascinated by your comments on recording yourself to compare sounds.
I did this very recently trying to decide between java and jazz select reeds, and although they felt and sounded way different to me when playing them, listening back I was pushed to tell which was which. They both sounded like “me”.
I was pleased to read someone else with the same experience – so players take note; it’s about pleasing yourself. The audience mostly won’t tell a difference.
AR