Reviewed: Alexander Alto and Tenor Saxophone Reeds
One of the biggest issues that saxophonists must deal with is the challenge of finding a good reed. We all know what it’s like to buy a box of reeds and come across some reeds that are either too hard, too soft, mis-cut, warped, or chipped. Although there is not a reed manufacturer today who can guarantee a box of five or ten reeds for soprano, alto, tenor, or bari saxophone that all play consistently and evenly throughout the entire range of the horn, Alexander clearly seeks to achieve that goal.
Alexander Reeds, was founded by Tom Alexander after he became tired of the inconsistencies with the reeds currently on the market. Instead of searching for another brand of reed to try out, he decided to manufacturer his own line. Since the early 1990’s, Alexander Reeds has come out with the Superial, DC, Classique, and in 2007 came out with the NY. All models were cut for both saxophone and clarinet. What enticed me to try out this brand of reeds was the overall consistency that I have read about through online forums as well as my conversations with endorsing artists and local players who exclusively use Alexander reeds.
The reeds I am going to be reviewing are the Superial, Superial D.C., and NY for tenor saxophone and the Superial, and Superial D.C. for alto saxophone. With each box of Alexander reeds came a set of “preparation” instructions to help you maximize the reed’s playing potential. I used this method on some of the reeds that were a bit soft or hard and I noticed after a couple of days that many “so so” reeds gradually became better reeds that I would be happy to play on. (I’ve included Alexander’s preparation method at the end of this article.)
Superial (strength 3)
Tone: I found the Superial reed gave me a brighter tone. I found that from low Bb to C the reed responded very well, but what really caught my ear was when I played from middle C to high F#. In this range, I was able to produce a bright and centered tone in the palm keys which is something I have been struggling with when using other manufacture’s reeds.
Playability: The Superial reed played evenly throughout all registers of the horn. I felt like I could really push this reed and it would not die out. The response was instant when I put on the reed and it seemed to take very little time to break the reed in.
Consistency: Out of the 5 reeds I tried, three of them played great out of the box and on two of them I had to use the recommended preparation method, which seemed to make the reeds more playable.
Lifespan: I have been playing these reeds for over a week and rotating them. I have found no issues thus far in terms of the reeds dying out too soon. After playing over an hour a day and cycling through the Superial reeds, I have found no issues.
Comparison: The Superial Reeds are most similar to the Vandoren Java or the Standard Rico orange box
Superial D.C. (strength 3, personal favorite)
Tone: When I tried the Superial D.C. reeds I found out that I was able to produce a even and focused sound throughout the entire range of the horn. The sound was darker than the Superial and I found that the bottom range of the horn, down to the low Bb, had a really big and cutting sound.
Playability: I found the D.C.’s to be just as free-blowing as the Superial, but I liked the edge I was able to get with these reeds. I found these reeds to be very stable throughout the entire range of the horn when practicing my long tones. My high A, B, and C also had a more solid sound that did not seem thin or weak.
Consistency: I found the Superial D.C. to work well with my setup. Four out of the five reeds played great. With one of the reeds, I had to use the preparation method as well as a little sandpaper work to get it playing the way I wanted it to.
Lifespan: I believe due to this reed’s slightly harder tip as well as the relatively generous amount of wood in the heart, the lifespan of these reeds may be a bit more than that of the Superial.
Comparison: The Superial D.C. Reeds are most similar to the Vandoren ZZ, Rico Jazz Select, and Rico Royal
Alexander NY (strength 2.5)
Tone: According to the company’s website, Michael Brecker worked with Tom Alexander on designing this new cut. The tip was redesigned and is different from the Superial and Superial D.C. The new tip was designed to give the saxophonist a powerful and resonating sound. The intention was to give the saxophonists a little bit more of the tonal “edge” that is generally associated with many of the players in New York. With the NY cut, I was able to really lean into the upper register and get a loud and full sound when I went up to the palm keys.
Playability: The NY was very free blowing like the Superial, and Superial D.C. I found very little resistance when playing throughout the entire range of the horn.
Consistency: With the NY, I actually found these reeds to be a bit harder (even with a 2.5) than the Superial and Superial D.C. Because of this, I decided to use the Alexander preparation method which made three out of the five play very well. On the other two, I used sandpaper to shave them down and make them softer.
Lifespan: I would have to say the lifespan of these reeds would be similar to the Superial D.C.’s.
Comparison: The Alexander NY Reeds are most similar to the Vandoren V16, La Voz, and Hemke.
Superial (strength 3, personal favorite)
Tone: When I played the Superial reed on alto, I found it to give a bright and edgy tone that you would most associate with a lead alto in a big band.
Playability: These reeds were as free-blowing as the ones I tried on tenor.
Consistency: Four out of the five reeds played great, and I ended up shaving off a little bit on the fifth one since it was a bit stiff.
Lifespan: Since I have been rotating these reeds every couple of days, I have had no issues in any reeds getting too soft or just-plain dying out.
D.C. (strength 3)
Tone: When I played the Superial D.C., I found these reeds to have a darker but somewhat warmer sound compared to the bright and cutting sound of the Superial reeds.
Playability: I found these reeds to be harder than the Superial reeds, but still very playable through the entire range of the horn.
Consistency: I found that I used the recommend preparation method on three out of the five reeds, which made them a bit more free-blowing and easier to play.
Lifespan: These reeds had a similar lifespan to the Superial. I have had no issues thus far and have not seen any issues of reeds dying out or becoming too soft.
I would have to say that Alexander offers a line of reeds that many saxophonist will enjoy playing. I found the overall consistency of these reeds to be better than other brands I have tried and believe that the combination of the product and the preparation method Alexander recommends is what sets these reeds apart from other reed manufacturers.
For additional information, that you would like to know please visit http://www.superial.com/home.html
If you have any questions or have played Alexander reeds, please leave a comment to let me know what you think.
As promised, here is the preparation method from the Alexander website:.
“We suggest that you break the reeds in by first soaking them for about 2-4 minutes in lukewarm to warm water, and making sure that the whole vamp, and not just the tip alone, gets wet (a reed that is too dry or only wet at the very tip might tend to squeak). Some players, especially in dry weather, prefer a little more soaking time and a some others like immersing the whole reed in the water. Then again, if you soak it for too long, it may end up becoming waterlogged, so try a balanced approach. And make sure you wet the reed each succeeding time you play thereafter, though you may find that as it gets broken in, less soaking time will be necessary.
After the soaking is operation is done, place the reed you want to prepare on glass or a similar flat surface and massage it (starting from the back of the vamp slope) with your finger or fingers several strokes forward towards the tip, in order to help close off the fiber ends and stabilize the cane.
Then comes the break-in secret, which is certainly no original idea of mine, but a time tested practice for reed longevity:
Break in the reeds you prepare by only playing them at no louder than mp-m and for the first day only a few minutes and maybe 5-10 minutes the second day.
By breaking them in at mezzo or softer and for not too long in the first couple of days, the reeds should last longer and be more stable for full bore playing later. Playing them all out in fortissimo from the first 2 days might overstress the tips.
The exception to the break in is: If the new reed you try feels a good bit too hard, you can skip the break in period and just play in normally from the first day.
A tendency of these reeds is to harden a little after a few days of playing, so you may find a slightly softer reed that will end up being perfect in a few days after break in. If you find a reed that is too hard even if you skip the break in.”
May 17, 2012 @ 11:01 am
I absolutely love these reeds. I’ve tried pretty much all of them and have settled with NY #3s. When opening them though, I do go through the instructions that come with the reeds and not just play them out of the case. They seem to last a bit longer that way.
May 19, 2012 @ 9:09 pm
I agree with you Tibbs. So far, I like the Superial D.C. for tenor and the Superial’s for alto. I can definitely add these reeds to brands I like to play on. Before Alexander reeds I was playing on rigotti and jazz rico select reeds, which I still play on and like, but have found these reeds to give me the comfort I am looking for. Hope players enjoy these reeds as much as you have.
May 22, 2012 @ 4:46 pm
Bought 6 boxes over the last year. I had very poor luck with these reeds. out of the box 1 in 5 played as one would hope even with the break in. Used mostly the NY Tenor 2.5 and found them harder than most vandoren of the same number. The cuts on the reeds were very inconsistent from the rail to the tip. I had saved the last box to show the rep how bad they were and they said they would replace them. So I sent them in, they did not replace them or even reply. Moved on! At $25 per box of 5 I would expect no less than 3 in each box to be good. Not the case.
May 22, 2012 @ 6:46 pm
I am sorry to hear about your troubles with Alexander reeds. What reeds did you play on or currently play on before you purchased the Alexander Reeds? I also found the Alexander NY 2.5 to be a bit harder than the vandoren’s but did not find any inconsistencies from the rail to the tip. Please let me know what rep you reached out to so I can get in contact with them and inform Alexander about your problem. I will let you know what he says.
June 8, 2012 @ 2:44 pm
I have spoken to Alexander reeds and was wondering if you could send me your email or email me so I can tell you what they said.
June 8, 2012 @ 3:16 pm
feel free to email me Zach
July 5, 2012 @ 7:23 am
Zach did you forget about me?
July 5, 2012 @ 3:34 pm
I did not forget about you. I have heard back from Alexander and have been trying to email you, but I don’t have your email address. Could you give me your email address so that I could send you what the Alexander team had to say about your current situation.
July 5, 2012 @ 4:26 pm
the email is in the reply thread dated June 8th
here it is again email@example.com
August 1, 2012 @ 3:43 am
Did you receive my email with Alexander’s response?
August 1, 2012 @ 6:15 am
Sorry I did not receive your response please try again Zachary. Thanks
October 17, 2012 @ 6:13 pm
I first used Alexander reeds sometime ago when I bought a tin box containing 20 Superial DCs. (I don’t think boxes of 20 are still available). I absolutely loved them. However, recent purchases have proven to be very disappointing – e.g., split and unevenly cut and unresponsive. I have stopped buying them. (If I remember correctly, following endorsment by Joshua Redman, the quality dropped). It seems that like so many products, once they become popular, quality drops.
October 19, 2012 @ 11:43 am
Gary I agree. one of the reasons I was given for bad reeds by an Alexander rep was that they sometimes stay in a warehouse in unfavorable climate conditions. My thought is then don’t store them there first off and what does that have to do with the bad cuts. I did in all honesty get a box of DC alto #2 that seem to be in pretty good shape very recently. I like the reeds when they play…. but the tenor box I bought at the same time I opened at the store and handed them right back to the dealer he looked at them and agreed they did not look right, he took them back.
October 22, 2012 @ 8:43 am
Well, I have faced the reed issue with other reed manufactureres. I have to agree with both randy and gary that the way these reeds are stored probably has a major impact on their playability as well as how they are packaged and shipped.
May 25, 2020 @ 2:14 pm
If I play a Select Jazz 3s on Tenor what Alexander NY jazz reed strength would I need ?
May 25, 2020 @ 4:03 pm
I’ve included a link to the D’Addario reed comparison chart. On alexander’s website, they state to compare the reed strength of there reeds to a vandoren traditional blue box. My thought would be if a D’Addario Select Jazz 3s is similar to a Vandoren blue box 2.5 then I would buy the Alexander NY 2.5 reed strength. I will say of all the Alexander reed types, the Superial was my favorite. If you were concerned about the reed being to soft then I recommend always going up a half step and using a reedgeek or light sand paper (reedgeek is better) to remove some cane so the reed is less hard.
Hope this helps