Is It Time to Teach?
This is a guest post from saxophonist and educator David Erato of DavidErato.com.
You’ve taken lessons for a few years or more. You have basic knowledge of music theory and proficiency on your horn. It may be time to share your knowledge with others. But to what degree? Will teaching be your main source of income, or will it be for extra reed money as you go through college? Or it might not be time to take on students at all. I’ll address each scenario below.
When Not To Teach
If you are a musically talented high school student, you may be asked from someone in your neighborhood if you can give lessons to their little Sally who is just starting the saxophone in the 5th grade. While I do think you may serve as an important role model in Sally’s musical career, you shouldn’t engage in regularly scheduled weekly lessons and accept money from Sally’s mom. Absolutely become Sally’s mentor and show her things you’ve learned (and feel free to accept baked goods from time to time in exchange for your time), but be sure to refer Sally to your local teacher. The student-teacher relationship is very unique, and there are lots of pedagogic principals to consider that require careful study and a mature mind. There are acceptable musical relationships you can have with younger students in your neighborhood, but the student-teacher one is not recommended unless you are trained in that field.
Another situation where it may not be right to accept money in exchange for music lessons is when you are not teaching your primary instrument. There are many intricacies to the saxophone that need finessing during points in a student’s learning track (like the embouchure, alternate fingerings, etc.). If you haven’t spent more than a semester in college mastering the instrument you shouldn’t be teaching the instrument in a long form (30 minutes weekly) private lesson situation. There are a few exceptions. One is if you are the only music teacher in a rural area, and are really the only option that student has of learning music. Woodwind ‘doublers’ are also exempt from the primary instrument rule if they have the mentality that they approach each instrument as a primary instrument. Eddie Daniels couldn’t explain that approach any better than in this clip.
As a Side Gig
Being a music student in college can be a great time to start picking up a few students. You get to be active in a field you are pursuing a degree in, see if you really like teaching, and maybe make a few extra bucks for reeds. You may even be able to use the practice rooms at the school for lessons free of rent. Your teacher may even be able to pass some students to you. It’s a great time to start getting experience and hone your craft. I know I am a very different teacher now than I was when I had my first student.
Alternately, you may have a full time job (either in music or another field), but are interested in taking on some students on the side. The first thing to do would be to contact some of the local band directors in the area and let them know you’re looking for students. You should even make a flyer for the director to post. Word of mouth may spread and one student may turn into three pretty quickly. Be sure to know the good lesson teachers in the area as well. They may be booked solid and could pass some off to you and you may recommend students to them as well.
Since these lessons are on the side and not a primary source of income, the lessons can be more informal. By that I mean you don’t need a written policy or write invoices. You still may want to collect on a monthly basis, and reschedule missed lessons as they come, but that is up to you.
As a Primary Source of Income
One thing they usually don’t teach you while studying music in college is that you can make a living teaching private music lessons. Granted, it’s not a glamorous living by any means, but if you get enough students you can make a career out of teaching. Location is going to be key, especially for how you get your students and how much you can charge. It may be easier to fill a studio in an urban and suburban area than a rural area.
Your best location for making private teaching a career is to be connected with a music store or conservatory. You may also be able to teach lessons at a local school, be a traveling teacher and teach in homes, or teach out of your own home. The latter may require the most leg work in recruiting students. Write a bio, put up a website, update your resume, make a poster, and hit the streets. Visit music stores to see if they have any space to rent or positions available, and spread your name around to local band teachers as well. The more people you know the better chances you’ll have gain students.
Expect your hours to be after school, since most of your students most likely will be school aged (between ages 10 and 18, depending on when they start band at schools near you). You will probably have to teach 4 to 6 days a week in order to make a “full-time” wage, however the actual hours teaching per week is usually much less than full time for a “normal” job if you can charge enough. Full time salary for part time hours can be very nice. That gives you extra time during the week to practice and play gigs.
Be aware though, that you will be working many hours outside of the studio time spent with students, especially if you have a large number of students in your studio. Things like scheduling, re-scheduling, billing, preparing, picking out music, researching, etc. should be considered part of your job and consequently part of your pay as well. I will go more into detail on organizing and maintaining a large studio in a future guest post.
At the end of the day, teaching music needs to be motivated by the love of music and your need to spread the knowledge around – not about money. It is wonderful that one can make a career out of teaching music, which can also help support a performance career. But never forget what you love about music, and why it is important to help others acquire what you have discovered.
Photo by woodleywonderworks
Marc Plotkin
August 18, 2011 @ 3:58 pm
Very interest post. My only beef is I think the section about discouraging young players from teaching even younger players is a bit of an old-school mentality. Some of the more innovative schools have begun making final exams for students being based on how well a concept can be explained to another student. There are a multitude of scientific studies (just Google “Learning by Teaching”) supporting that this practice cements concepts in students who act as teachers much more than not.
I myself taught elementary school private lessons in my town back when I was in high school and it was one of the most enlightening experiences I ever had as a musician. It built up my complete understanding of whatever concept was being explained, greatly improved my communication skills, and started me on a path to correlating the musical knowledge I’ve built with compensation. Even though I didn’t have a music degree yet, I had been taking private lessons with a pro for years and essentially passed on what had been taught to me to youngsters.
I also think building an association of tangible value (accepting $ from Sally’s Mom) with the knowledge the student is imparting on the younger student would be a positive thing. We live in a world where most musicians are content providing their art and their knowledge to others for free (myself occasionally included). We might live in a world where musicians are respected more if at an early stage it’s not assumed that this is a work that goes unnoticed monetarily. I’m in no way suggesting emphasizing money over the heart and joy of just playing music, but starting to plant a seed that thinking about money in regards to teaching and playing music at a young stage seems to me to lead to a more balanced outlook and outcome.
Doron Orenstein
August 18, 2011 @ 9:57 pm
I have to say that I actually agree with you Mark. I also taught in high school – but I hated doing it so naturally I wasn’t exactly the world’s greatest teacher.
But I’m sure that there are some high school players out there who give college players and maybe even some pros a good run for their money, so I don’t think you can make a blanket statement that high school students should not be teaching, period (and I highly doubt that David was trying to say that, I think he was just thinking in terms of not screwing up younger students by passing on one’s own undeveloped playing habits).
Anyhow, thanks for chiming in my friend!
Saxophone Lessons
September 13, 2011 @ 2:02 pm
Some of the more innovative schools have begun making final exams for students being based on how well a concept can be explained to another student.
Google Business Listings
November 15, 2011 @ 6:51 am
I don’t think you can make a blanket statement that high school students should not be teaching