NAMM 2012 Saxophone Roundup
NAMM, NAMM, NAMM. What a great time. I got to try out a gaggle of saxophones, and best of all, I was able to meet in-person so many super-cool folks who I’ve come to know through starting this website. Folks like Charles McNeal, Tim Price, Bob Reynolds, Adam Larson, and Zach Sollitto, along with long-time heros such as Greg Osby, and Pete Christleib.
The video below is me hanging out at NAMM, trying out a bunch of different horns including those made by Selmer, P. Mauriat, Cannonball, Jupiter, Antigua Winds, and Chateau (I might be forgetting a brand or two, check out the video to see for sure). I also tried out some cheapo horns which were so terrible as to be literally, barely playable. Those manufacturers will remain nameless, but my heart goes out the poor students who get saddled with these saxophonic atrocities.
Also, to clarify, on the video, before the clip where I play the Chateau, you’ll hear me say “it’s my favorite of the horns I’ve tried here.” What I meant by that was that it as my favorite out of the Chateau horns that I tried. Same deal with the Cannonball horn, when I say “this is the one I like best.” I meant that was the Cannonball horn that I liked best. Still not sure what my favorite overall was, but I will say that the Chateau and Cannonball did play a lot better than I would have predicted.
One major bummer was that I also had footage of myself trying out a horn from RS Berkeley’s Virtuoso line, but that individual video file got corrupted and I simply could not get it into the final video try as I might.
Other Cool Stuff
You’ll also see me trying out the E-Sax saxophone mute made by Best Brass. As you’ll hear, it makes a huge difference in curtailing the volume of the horn, but man is it awkward to play. Not sure I could get used to it, but maybe if I could find one used for $100-200, it might be worth a try.
The was also the Synthofone which is an actual alto saxophone that serves as a MIDI controller, so you can play any synth or sampler via MIDI, which to me would make for a nice alternative to wind controllers such as the Yamaha WX7 or the Akai EWI, since both the Yamaha and the Akai come with significant learning curves before the average sax player is able to become fluent on those instruments.
Anyhow, I’d say just watch the video for the real lowdown. Enjoy!
To see some photos from my visit to NAMM, hop on over here.
So which of these horns sounds best to you?
Dan
February 17, 2012 @ 8:05 am
What mpc youre using and reed?
Doron Orenstein
February 17, 2012 @ 8:57 am
Hey Dan,
I’m using an Otto Link Babbit model and a Vandoren Java 3 reed.
Doron
Jim
February 23, 2012 @ 8:25 am
you sound really good on the Mac8 to me.
Doron Orenstein
February 23, 2012 @ 8:47 am
Thanks Jim, that’s what I was thinking as well! I would love to have them send me one to review in more detail at some point, but yeah, I think that Macsax is going to be a bigger player in the next few years.
Slab
March 28, 2012 @ 3:05 pm
I’m real curious about the new Theo Wanne sax. Did you get a chance to try it? I’m looking forward to a good review, as I haven’t found one yet.
Doron Orenstein
March 28, 2012 @ 8:59 pm
Unfortunately, that was one of the horns I didn’t get to try (there were so many!). However, Tim Price tried it out and have very, very good things to say about it. I hope that helps!
James
May 27, 2012 @ 3:59 pm
Hi Doron.
Nice video on Namm saxes- the best one I’ve seen!
I was impressed with macsax but for their price range ($3200) or so for the Mac8- theres a lot of close competition. The chateau’s to me look nice and really sound great- I’m going to look at the nickel bodied one more closely but for just under $2000 its impressive. Finally the selmer serie 3 had a lovely focussed sound to me and quite distinctive from the pack- not better- just characteristic of the brand…..
Doron Orenstein
May 30, 2012 @ 6:18 pm
Thanks for the kind words, James! Yeah, many of these horn’s aren’t cheap, but compared to the cost of the the Mark VI that these horns are trying to emulate, I suppose that one could say that they’re a pretty good option in terms of pricing.
Ed Crotts
May 2, 2013 @ 3:47 pm
Doron —
Did you have a chance to compare the Chateau tenors regarding amount of copper content, e.g., 70, 85 vs 92%, as well as standard vs rolled tone holes? Would guess you might have experienced a bit more “darkness”/warmth in tone w/ the 85 and 92% and also w/ rolled tone holes. Comments? Thanks!
Doron Orenstein
May 5, 2013 @ 11:41 am
Hello Ed,
Haha, you’re obviously way more savvy than me when it comes to sax gear. I always tell people that I’m more of a music geek than a sax gear geek. In fact, I’m pretty ignorant about things like copper content and standard vs. rolled tone holes, so I’m sorry I can’t answer your questions. For this reason, I’ve got my man Zach Sollitto doing all of the product reviews on the site, as he’s a true gear head.
I basically just tried the horns out and tired to get a sense of which ones sounded and felt the best.
I guess you’ll just have to make it out to NAMM yourself, maybe next year!
Best.
Doron